arXiv AI

Type-Safe Is Not Error-Free: A Constrained Decision Head Follows the Option Name, Not the Rubric Bound to It

The study examines how renaming option labels in typed decision models affects model behavior. By swapping the names of two options (e.g., from 0/1 to no/yes) while keeping the underlying rubrics unchanged, the authors observed a dramatic shift in decision rankings—AUC dropped from .94 to .23 and answer flips increased by 70.4 per hundred. The effect is amplified with more options and depends on the semantic polarity of the labels, yet the models still maintain a zero type‑error rate.

arXiv AI
Oct 9

Type-Safe Is Not Error-Free: Typed Decision Models Follow the Option Name, Not the Definition Bound to It

The paper demonstrates that typed decision models can produce type‑correct outputs that nevertheless do not adhere to the explicit definitions of their options. By swapping only the names of options while keeping the definitions, question, and state unchanged, the authors show that decision flips can increase dramatically—up to 70.4 percentage points—when using yes/no names versus neutral controls. This effect is consistent across multiple models and decision rules, and even random strings as names yield flip rates similar to neutral controls, indicating that option‑name polarity contributes to decision instability beyond mere reassignment.

By Yu Sun, Junhao Xu, Jiajia Shi, Zijin Yang
arXiv Computation and Language
Nov 4

Swap, Replicate, Read the Mass: A Protocol for Auditing Demographic Bias in System One Decision Models

The paper introduces a comprehensive audit protocol for System One decision models, which provide typed, probability‑scored answers without human oversight. Using three adapted benchmarks—BBQ, CrowS‑Pairs, and SilverSpoon—it evaluates twelve models plus a no‑thinking baseline across 1,638,000 decisions, revealing widespread stereotype alignment, order‑dependent responses, and confidence instability. The study demonstrates that swapping answer options and reversing question order significantly alters model outputs, underscoring the need for order‑invariant scoring in procurement.

By Alejandro Mozo Quesada (Universidad de M\'alaga, Spain), Sergio G\'alvez Rojas (Universidad de M\'alaga, Spain), Francisco L\'opez Valverde (Universidad de M\'alaga, Spain)
arXiv Machine Learning
Oct 3

Benchmarking System One decision models against trained classifiers and language models for automated decision gates

The paper evaluates System One decision models—typed models that output probabilities for branching decisions—against supervised classifiers and generative language models on automated decision gate tasks. Eight checkpoints from six families, including the hosted model Jev, were benchmarked on workflow, intent, and social‑science items, showing that small trained classifiers match or slightly outperform decision models on intent and workflow when labels are available, while decision models outperform zero‑shot classifiers when labels are absent. The study also explores calibration, risk thresholds, and cost‑efficiency trade‑offs, providing condition‑dependent design guidelines for automated decision gates.

By Amir Rafe, Subasish Das
arXiv Computation and Language
Oct 28

Do We Need an LLM to Know Why Sources Conflict? Decision Models for Knowledge-Conflict Typing in RAG

The paper investigates whether fast, cost‑efficient decision models can classify the type of conflict among retrieved sources for a query, a task that improves response quality when the conflict type is known. Using the CONFLICTS benchmark, the authors evaluate 11 commercial decision models against Gemini LLMs, finding that most achieve 50–67% accuracy, often matching or surpassing Gemini 2.5 Flash while incurring 4–39× lower cost and 2.6–6.0× lower latency. A cascade approach that forwards uncertain cases to Gemini 3.8 Flash yields comparable performance at only 25–37% of its cost, and the resulting typed responses generally behave as expected when compared to LLM‑derived types.

By Parv Khatri, Harshul Jain, Mehak Kapoor, Tanya Sah
arXiv AI
Oct 9

One Word Opens the Gate: The Option-Channel Attack on Typed Decision Models as Agent Guardrails

The paper investigates typed decision models used as guardrails in agent systems, evaluating seven open‑weight models on tasks such as prompt‑injection, jailbreak, and toxic‑content screening. Accuracy for allow‑or‑block decisions ranges from 36% to 72% above chance, with models either over‑allowing or over‑blocking. The authors demonstrate that simple textual manipulations—like adding misleading names or server log lines—can dramatically increase fail‑open rates, and that all tested defenses can be bypassed, suggesting these models are unsuitable as the sole decision component.

By Seyedarmin Azizi, Erfan Baghaei Potraghloo, Massoud Pedram