The paper examines whether AI‑driven debate can help humans and weaker language models (LLMs) correct their judgments. Experiments show that debate improves human accuracy over prior beliefs, especially with weighted voting, but offers little benefit—and sometimes harms—accuracy for weaker LLM supervisors. The study highlights debate as a promising tool for scalable human oversight while questioning its effectiveness for fully automated AI control.
By Maria Victoria Carro, Denise Alejandra Mester, Facundo Nieto, Oscar Agustin Stanchi, Guido Ernesto Bergman, Giovanni Franco Gabriel Marrafini, Trinidad Borrell, Guido Freire, Joaquin Salvador Machulsky, Mario Alejandro Leiva, Ana Lopez, Nicolas Spinelli, Luca Nicolas Forziati Gangi, Eitan Sprejer, Federico Barrera Lemarchand, Gerardo Simari, Maria Vanina Martinez
arXiv:2606. 11217v1 Announce Type: cross Abstract: The proliferation of large language models (LLMs) and autonomous AI agents has given rise to a rapidly growing methodological paradigm: "in silico" behavioral experiments.
By Michelle Vaccaro
The paper investigates whether multi-agent deliberation (MAD)—where several large language models (LLMs) engage in structured, multi-round discussion—helps humans make better decisions. Two user studies compare MAD to single-round AI assistance and examine the impact of adding a second AI and of multi-round interaction, finding that repeated interaction is the main driver of improved performance. The authors also explore design choices such as AI persona and human engagement level, noting that a devil’s advocate persona reduces accuracy and experience, while active human participation can boost accuracy at the cost of frustration.
By Harry Yizhou Tian, Ming Yin
The study tests deliberately biased AI assistants and finds that such bias improves human performance on tasks like misinformation evaluation, financial investment, and graduate education compared to neutral AI. However, participants undervalue biased AI and overvalue neutral AI, even when performance is similar. When two AI biases flank a participant’s perspective, performance gains are maintained while reducing the perceived cost and one‑sided influence.
By Shiyang Lai, Jiwoong Choi, Junsol Kim, Nadav Kunievsky, Yujin Potter, James Evans
arXiv:2608. 14522v1 Announce Type: new Abstract: As AI systems make more morally loaded decisions across society, one response has been moral preference elicitation.
By Taenyun Kim, Edyta Bogucka, Daniele Quercia
arXiv:2509.08494v2 Announce Type: replace-cross
Abstract: As humans delegate more tasks and decisions to artificial intelligence (AI), we risk losing control of our individual and collective futures....
By Benjamin Sturgeon, Daniel Samuelson, Jacob Haimes, Jacy Reese Anthis