arXiv AI

Ethical LLM-Assisted Research: A Framework for Responsible Delegation, Verification, and Epistemic Value

The paper proposes a normative framework for ethical use of large language models (LLMs) in scientific research, treating reasoning as a distributed process where human control remains essential for epistemic legitimacy. It introduces key constructs—content origin, human verification, responsibility assignment, accountable ownership, and epistemic outcome—to separate claim provenance from verification and responsibility. The authors argue that the ethical boundary hinges on adequate verification and accountable human ownership, and they propose an "epistemic audit" to document delegation, verification, provenance, and responsibility for transparent, reviewable AI-assisted reasoning.

arXiv AI
Oct 2

Cybernetic and Epistemic: A Missing Vocabulary for Trustworthy Agentic Delegation

The paper argues that as AI systems increasingly generate code, the bottleneck has shifted to supervising these systems, revealing a vocabulary gap between cybernetic coordination (actions aligning with the world) and epistemic coordination (understanding that can be verified). It critiques current oversight that merely approves outputs, proposing instead that every consequential choice by an agent must include a retrievable condition explaining why it was made, enabling third‑party verification. The authors illustrate this with three delegation episodes, introduce a two‑part reconstruction test, and propose the ORRCF convention to embed such conditions in all recorded decisions.

By J\'er\'emie Lumbroso
arXiv Machine Learning
Jul 1

The Calibration Turn in AI-Assisted Research: A Conceptual and Methodological Framework for Evidence-Licensed Claims

arXiv:2606. 31273v1 Announce Type: new Abstract: AI-assisted research has entered a stage in which the central question is not only whether systems can generate hypotheses, run experiments, or produce manuscripts, but whether their scientific claims are calibrated to the evidence that supports them.

By Hongmin Li
arXiv AI
6d ago

Epistemic Infrastructures of Science in AI Era Should Rebalance Costs of Generation and Verification

The paper argues that AI can cheaply produce plausible scientific artifacts, leading to epistemic pollution because the existing scientific infrastructure relies on high generation costs as a filter. It proposes rebalancing generation and verification costs by introducing structured "blueprints"—typed graph components that decompose claims, evidence, assumptions, and definitions—so that verification becomes cheaper, more local, and distributed. The blueprint complements traditional papers, serving as a verification interface while the paper remains the narrative interface, and a prototype demonstrates the concept.

By Jiaqi W. Ma
arXiv AI
Oct 28

Why and How to Do Science When AI Is Better at It: A Framework Grounded in Human Understanding and Direction

The paper explores why humans should continue conducting science as AI becomes increasingly capable, arguing that science’s essential goal is durable, collective human understanding of the world for human ends and values. It proposes a two-part test—human understanding and human direction—to decide when research tasks can be delegated to AI, applying this framework across all research phases, including peer review and training. The authors emphasize that this guidance remains relevant even if AI outperforms humans, focusing on the impact of AI on human understanding and accountability rather than on tool type or current AI limitations.

By Hoda Heidari, Aydin Mohseni
arXiv AI
Sep 7

When Does an Interpretation Count as Established? The Formation, Evaluation, and Responsibility of Interpretation in Generative AI

The paper investigates when an interpretation in generative AI is considered established, arguing that passing local factual checks is insufficient. It introduces three concepts—interpretive appearance, evaluation contract, and standing substitution—to analyze how interpretations gain recognition within sociotechnical processes. The authors propose delayed closure as a practice to keep recognized interpretations revisable and outline five public requirements for transparency, evidence, failure handling, contract revision, and responsibility.

By Deyu Jing