When and How Should an Agent Clarify? CIGAsk: Teaching LLMs to Clarify via Counterfactual Information Gain
Read the original on arXiv AI →The Flow has not summarised this story yet — read it at arXiv AI.
The Flow has not summarised this story yet — read it at arXiv AI.
CLEAT (CLarification through valuE-guided Agent co-Training) is a framework that jointly trains a clarification-value controller and a task policy to improve interactive intent alignment in large language model agents. It introduces a residual query value metric, estimated via paired rollouts, to assess the utility of asking clarification questions and uses this to guide both controller predictions and policy decisions. Experiments with Qwen3-4B show CLEAT outperforming baselines across multiple benchmarks, with significant gains in user‑centric tasks and demonstrating that co‑training benefits the task policy even when the controller is omitted at inference.
The paper investigates strategic clarification in dialogue, focusing on when large language models should ask clarification questions versus providing immediate answers to resolve ambiguous references. Using a controlled test environment derived from the SIMMC 2.1 dataset, the authors evaluate baseline LLM behavior and post‑training methods, noting a bias toward premature answering. They introduce BACE, a lightweight belief‑aware critic that tracks epistemic uncertainty, and demonstrate that it more consistently selects the optimal number of clarifying questions compared to methods like GRPO and ArCHer.
The paper introduces VagueBench, a benchmark that degrades seed queries into vague variants to evaluate large language models’ ability to ask follow‑up questions when user queries are incomplete. It proposes DialogGRPO, an offline reinforcement learning approach that models multi‑turn elicitation as a dialogue‑state directed acyclic graph, using dense turn‑level rewards to guide question selection. DialogGRPO achieves over 88% success in eliciting missing information on vague queries, improves answer coverage and recovery efficiency, and outperforms prompting and test‑time scaling baselines while generalizing zero‑shot to other dialogue datasets.
arXiv:2608. 12764v1 Announce Type: cross Abstract: Deep search agents operate over trajectories spanning dozens of steps, yet standard reinforcement learning provides only a single outcome reward per trajectory, which is far too sparse for effective credit assignment.
arXiv:2606. 03135v1 Announce Type: new Abstract: Large Language Model (LLM) agents often operate under underspecified user instructions, where latent uncertainty over user intent leads to erroneous tool actions.
The paper introduces VAKE, a two‑stage reinforcement‑learning framework that activates latent factual knowledge in large language models. In the Priming stage, the model explicitly inserts bridging triples into an insufficient subgraph, guided by rewards from a frozen model’s answers. The Reasoning stage then trains the model to answer from the original input, demonstrating that the elicitation capability transfers to implicit reasoning and consistently outperforms baselines across multiple benchmarks and model sizes.