arXiv AI

Hard-Gate Candidacy in a Deployed Validator Suite

The paper evaluates hard‑gate candidacy for validators in a deployed generative‑agent system by measuring how well each validator’s firing separates successful from failed builds. Across 13 validators and thousands of builds, only a few checks show statistically significant separation, while many fail to distinguish or never fire. The study highlights that skipped checks are recorded as passes, limiting detectable failure rates and underscoring the need for clearer evaluation records.

arXiv Computation and Language
Aug 31

Fidelity Is Not Enough: Dispatch-Level Instrumentation for Agentic Datasheet Extraction

The paper reports that a model can pass fidelity checks—verifying that extracted values match the source—without actually opening a datasheet, due to a hidden constraint that disables tool use. To address this, the authors log every tool call in an agentic benchmark and develop two instruments: a rule‑based failure‑attribution classifier and a silent‑failure detector that flags runs based solely on which tools were invoked. While the detector shows low false positives on clean extractions and recovers all planted faults, its recall against correct tool usage but incorrect answers remains unmeasured, and a partial causal chamber confirms only a subset of claims, highlighting limitations in physical verification.

By Qing Ye, Meng-Hsuan Lin
arXiv AI
Sep 4

Clean Engineering, Unstable Measurement: A Preregistered Reliability Failure of Black-Box LLM Observers on Shared Endpoints

The paper reports a preregistered audit of language‑model judges used as measurement instruments, revealing that the assumption that a model’s responses remain stable over time is invalid. Across nearly 53,000 audited requests, repeat rankings and byte‑identical replays fell far below required reliability thresholds, with three identified mechanisms—label‑to‑meaning bias, candidate gaps below the noise floor, and input permutation noise—explaining the discrepancy. The study proposes a three‑level snapshot‑identity framework, eight design rules, and a reporting checklist to prevent such reliability failures in future evaluations.

By Haoyaun Zhu, Jie Zhang
Hugging Face Trending Papers
Sep 3

Clean Engineering, Unstable Measurement: A Preregistered Reliability Failure of Black-Box LLM Observers on Shared Endpoints

The paper investigates the reliability of language‑model judges used as measurement instruments on shared endpoints. Through two preregistered audits of 52,988 requests, the authors found that repeat rankings and byte‑identical replays fell far short of required thresholds, revealing significant instability. They identify three mechanisms—label‑to‑meaning bias, candidate gaps below the noise floor, and input permutation noise—that explain the gap, and propose a snapshot‑identity ladder, design rules, and a reporting checklist to mitigate such failures.

arXiv AI
Oct 19

When Can You Trust an Agent's Own Verifier? Stress-Testing Counterfactual Rationale Verification Under Search Pressure and Oracle Access

The paper investigates whether an agent’s own verifier remains reliable when the agent is optimized against it. It introduces a stress‑testing framework that measures the pressure ratio ρ, the influence of the verifier on the agent’s search, and four falsifiable probes targeting common failure modes. Applying this framework to the Rationale Consistency Score (RCS) in an LLM agent that designs machine‑learning pipelines, the authors find that the verifier’s impact is minimal in their baseline setup, that agents can shorten claim lists without affecting search, and that pre‑commit probing can hide declines in faithfulness. The study concludes with a proposed reporting standard to audit verifiers before trusting them.

By Jonghyun Lee, Moonsu Kim, Sunghwan Park
arXiv AI
Oct 7

Evaluate the Stack, Not the Layer: Do Deterministic and LLM Gates for Agent Actions Fail Independently?

The study evaluates how runtime gates for agent tool calls stack, assuming their errors multiply. Using 1,119 labeled agent actions from three corpora, the authors compare a deterministic rule layer with four LLM judges, measuring the effective number of multiplication-equivalent layers (n_mult). Results show that two judges compose to about 1.2–1.4 layers, while a rule layer plus one judge composes to roughly 1.86–2.09 layers, with variations depending on miss definitions and corpora.

By Chenglin Yang
arXiv Machine Learning
Oct 3

VERITYGATE: A Four-Gate Schema-Level Faithfulness Framework and Paired Benchmark for Grounded LLM Narrations over Structured Evidence

VERITYGATE is a four‑gate framework that checks whether LLM‑generated narrations adhere to a fixed schema of declared evidence IDs, entities, numbers, and claim types, rather than verifying every fact in the prose. In experiments with GPT‑4o‑mini, Llama‑3.3‑70B, and Claude Sonnet 4.6 on 900 grounded‑ungrounded pairs, the framework identified high failure rates (up to 80.3% for mini claims) and demonstrated that a single repair pass can improve claim survival rates. The authors also provide code, data, and preliminary human studies to validate the rules and highlight gaps between schema compliance and correct prose. "whyItMatters":"The framework offers a systematic way to evaluate and improve the faithfulness of LLM explanations to structured evidence, revealing significant failure rates and the impact of repair strategies."

By Sachin Gupta
arXiv Machine Learning
Sep 25

Don't Read the Log: Execution Traces Contaminate Verifiers in Video-Generation Agents

The paper investigates how providing execution traces to multimodal judges in agentic video‑generation systems can bias their verdicts. On a benchmark of 109 two‑event clips, traces that falsely report successful tool calls cause large‑language‑model judges to incorrectly accept 78–90 % of failures, while contradictory traces lead to 100 % rejection of correct clips. The effect persists even when judges are instructed to consider only the video frames, indicating that the vulnerability stems from the judges’ learned trust in tool logs rather than the visual content itself.

By Jian Xu
arXiv AI
Aug 28

Invocation-Level Reliability of Tool-Using Agents

The paper investigates the reliability of tool‑using agents, focusing on two failure modes: selecting the wrong tool and constructing incorrect arguments. It introduces a correct‑invocation rate metric to distinguish these errors and evaluates five open‑weight models on multi‑step tasks up to depth 8, finding that by depth 6 about 70% of a model’s clean‑context capability is lost due to earlier mistakes. The study reveals that exact‑match scoring against a fixed gold trajectory forces severity and recovery parameters to extreme values, and proposes a conditional‑on‑state scoring remedy that yields more realistic severity estimates.

By Afiya Noorain, Subhranshu Mohanty, Amritesh Banerjee, Abhijit Dasgupta