arXiv Computation and Language

Agent-as-a-Judge

arXiv AI
Oct 7

EIO-Agents: The Missing Semantic Layer for AI Agent Evaluation

EIO-Agents introduces an open specification for interoperable AI agent evaluation, consisting of two layers: the Evaluation Intelligence Ontology (EIO) and the Portable Evaluation Record (PER). The EIO layer supplies a semantic framework that defines typed evidence, behavioral predicates, evidence contracts, claims, witness rules, proof status, recurrence, and computable derivations for metrics, findings, controls, and decisions such as PASS, REVIEW, or BLOCK. The PER layer offers a canonical, content‑addressed record of an evaluation that preserves the evidence‑to‑decision chain, enabling re‑derivation, explanation, and verification of the evaluation outcome.

By Fouad Bousetouane
Hugging Face Trending Papers
Aug 6

SkillTV-Bench: Benchmarking How Well Judges Perform on Skill-Augmented Agentic Execution

LLM agents increasingly execute long-horizon tasks through tool use and environment interaction, shifting evaluation from final-response scoring to verification of complete executions. For skill-augmented agents, verification additionally requires the procedural knowledge encoded in task-time skills, because this knowledge indicates what evidence to inspect and which failures are task-critical.

arXiv AI
Jun 16

From Agent Traces to Trust: A Survey of Evidence Tracing and Execution Provenance in LLM Agents

arXiv:2606. 04990v2 Announce Type: replace-cross Abstract: Large language model (LLM)-based agents are evolving from passive text generators into autonomous systems capable of planning, tool use, retrieval, memory access, environmental interaction, and multi-agent collaboration.

By Yiqi Wang, Jiaqi Zhang, Taotao Cai, Zirui Liu, Qingqiang Sun, Zequn Sun, Zhangkai Wu, Manqing Dong, Mingkai Zhang, Xuefei Yin, Yanming Zhu
arXiv AI
Nov 6

Are LLM Safety Judges Policy-Invariant? A Three-Principle Stress-Test

The paper investigates whether large language model (LLM) safety judges are truly policy‑invariant, meaning their verdicts should depend only on the agent’s behavior and not on how the evaluation policy is phrased. It introduces three testable principles—rubric‑semantics invariance, rubric‑threshold invariance, and ambiguity‑aware calibration—and applies them in a stress‑test protocol across four agent‑class judges using trajectories from ASSEBench and R‑Judge. The study finds that current judges often change verdicts in response to both meaningful normative shifts and meaningless structural rewrites, with up to 9.1% of verdicts flipping due to content‑preserving rewrites and 18‑43% of flips occurring on unambiguous cases, indicating that safety scores conflate agent actions with evaluator wording. whyItMatters":"The findings reveal a hidden failure mode in safety evaluation that could mislead researchers about agent performance, underscoring the need for policy‑invariant judges and transparent reporting protocols."

By Shihao Weng, Yang Feng, Xiaofei Xie
arXiv AI
Jun 12

AgentBeats: Agentifying Agent Assessment for Openness, Standardization, and Reproducibility

arXiv:2606. 13608v1 Announce Type: new Abstract: Agent systems are advancing quickly across domains, but their evaluation remains fragmented.

By Xiaoyuan Liu, Jianhong Tu, Yuqi Chen, Siyuan Xie, Sihan Ren, Tianneng Shi, Gal Gantar, Evan Sandoval, Donghyun Lee, Daniel Miao, Peter J. Gilbert, Nick Hynes, Mauro Staver, Warren He, David Marn, Andrew Low, Xi Zhang, Elron Bandel, Michal Shmueli-Scheuer, Siva Reddy, Alexandre Drouin, Alexandre Lacoste, Ramayya Krishnan, Elham Tabassi, Yu Su, Victor Barres, Chenguang Wang, Wenbo Guo, Dawn Song
arXiv Computation and Language
Oct 22

SANE: Automated Scorer-Specific Metamorphic Testing for LLM Judges

SANE is an agent‑based framework that automatically generates scorer‑specific perturbation recipes and expected score relations for large‑language‑model judges, using behavioral requirements encoded as reusable agent instructions. It validates each recipe against the scorer’s intent and the instantiated test case, producing a growing inventory of aligned recipes as more scorers are added. In experiments across five domains, SANE yields 3.7× more validated test families than the Judge Reliability Harness, detects deficiencies in all domains—including professionalism and toxicity—and achieves strong human alignment in judge ranking on faithfulness (Spearman ρ = 0.852).

By Ethan Ludwick, Yu-Chung Hsiao
arXiv AI
Nov 5

Grounded but Not Immune: Confirmation Bias in Agent-as-a-judge

The paper investigates confirmation bias in Agent-as-a-Judge systems, which evaluate open-ended agent tasks by gathering evidence from the agent’s trajectory. It demonstrates that a single false pre‑screening note can overturn up to 40% of correct verdicts across multiple judges and datasets, even when the judge collects decisive evidence. The authors classify the resulting errors into over‑trust, hallucination, and under‑investigation, noting that over‑trust dominates in larger Claude judges, and show that lightweight mitigations reduce but do not eliminate the bias.

By Drake Benjamin Brown, Khushbu Pahwa, Yubin Ge, Salvatore Romeo, Akhil Agnihotri, Yi Zhang, Xiaofei Ma, Daniele Bonadiman
arXiv AI
Aug 28

AgentJudgeBench: A Multi-Difficulty Benchmark for Evaluating LLM Judges on Agentic Tool-Calling

AgentJudgeBench is a new benchmark that evaluates the reliability of large language model (LLM) judges on agentic tool‑calling tasks involving workflow directed acyclic graphs (DAGs). It contains 3,808 instances across six DAG topologies and three difficulty tiers, tested with five generators (3B–70B open‑weight models and GPT‑5.4) and six judges (20B to frontier scale) under both paired‑with‑and‑without‑ground‑truth conditions. The study finds that judge alignment degrades with task difficulty, ground‑truth exposure can sometimes hurt alignment, and structured evaluation rubrics provide modest improvements, revealing a structural ceiling that model capacity alone cannot surpass.

By Abhigya Verma, Amit Kumar Saha, Seganrasan Subramanian, Sai Harshitha Aluru