arXiv Computation and Language

The Schema Coherence Inventory: Measuring Whether an Assigned Belief Organizes a Language Model's Cognition

The paper introduces the Schema Coherence Inventory (SCI), a 96-item forced-choice test designed to determine whether a belief assigned to a persona-conditioned language model actually organizes its behavior or merely reflects affect. SCI evaluates belief organization across eight levels of Beck's cognitive model, using length‑normalized log‑likelihood scores and a target‑specificity criterion to distinguish true belief influence from mood effects. Validation across five model backbones (1.7B–14B parameters) and nine clinicians shows high reliability and discriminant validity, and a 48‑item short form correlates strongly with the full inventory.

arXiv AI
Aug 10

Natural Language Processing Psychometrics

arXiv:2608. 07316v1 Announce Type: cross Abstract: Natural Language Processing (NLP) models predicting mental health outcomes rarely specify what they measure: contextual knowledge, emotional content, or syntactic structure.

By Edoardo Sebastiano De Duro, Emma Franchino, Massimo Stella
arXiv AI
Sep 1

The Unsampled Truth: Quantifying Prompt Artifacts in LM Psychometrics

The study investigates how different prompt components affect language model responses in psychometric tests. By crossing five distinct baseline personas with five variants of each prompt element—persona wording, task instruction, item wording, and option symbol—the authors measure response shifts using the 1‑Wasserstein distance. Their analysis of 13 small open‑weight language models on the Big Five Inventory and Short Dark Triad reveals that task instruction and option symbol changes often cause more variation than paraphrasing the persona or item, with prompt artifacts explaining over 50% of the variation for many items.

By Nils Schwager, Christoph Hau, Simon M\"unker, Achim Rettinger
arXiv Computation and Language
3d ago

Which Answer Did the Seventeen-Year-Old Write? A Behavioral Case Study of Author-Age Misattribution, Miscalibrated Confidence, and Non-Corrective Self-Explanation in Six Frontier Language Models

The paper reports a structured case study in which six frontier language models were asked to match handwritten exam answers to the ages of the writers. Three of the models performed at chance on the matching task while still reporting high confidence, and the youngest writer’s answer was misattributed to an adult in up to 90% of trials. Removing the multiple‑choice scaffold and changing institutional framing further degraded accuracy, while a single audience‑awareness instruction improved performance for one model but had no effect on the weakest models.

By Brianne Lee
arXiv AI
Aug 26

How much of a measured AI preference is the model, and how much is the instrument?

The paper investigates how much of an AI model’s expressed preferences are due to the model itself versus the instrument (prompt) used to elicit those preferences. By fixing the set of outcomes and models while varying five different prompting instruments across 15 welfare-related outcomes, the study finds that the ranking of outcomes is only moderately generalizable (coefficient 0.348) and that a single instrument’s preference provides little insight into another instrument’s results. The analysis shows that even after removing any single instrument, model, or a subset of outcomes, the overall preference estimate remains robust, yet the variability across instruments remains significant.

By Jason Hung
arXiv AI
Jul 7

Where do LLMs Fall Short in CBT-Guided Affective Reasoning?

arXiv:2607. 02885v1 Announce Type: cross Abstract: Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) provides a structured framework for understanding a user's mental state by examining the interaction between cognitive and behavioral factors.

By Vaishnavi Sinha, Pooja Guttal, Pranay Deep Reddy Katike, Vishal Sinha, Gerald Ndawula, Lira Yoon, Andrea Kleinsmith, Manas Gaur