arXiv AI

When Expert Disagreement Hurts: Prestige and Selectivity in LLM Decision Revision

The study introduces a two‑pass audit to evaluate how language models revise decisions when faced with disagreement. By fixing the question, evidence, and initial answer, the audit isolates the effect of different revision contexts—neutral reflection, anonymous disagreement, or disagreement from a domain expert—on accuracy. Across five models and 1,989 evidence‑grounded decisions in medicine, science, and law, expert disagreement rarely improves accuracy, often reducing it by up to 16.1 points, and the number of reversals is a poor indicator of harm.

arXiv AI
Sep 30

When Should LLMs Trust Their Own Revisions? A Risk-Aware Study of Intrinsic Self-Correction

The paper investigates intrinsic self‑correction, where a language model revises its own answer without new evidence. Across 29 open‑weight LLMs on BoolQ, GSM8K, and Corr2Cause, the study tracks how revisions change correctness, revealing that while some models improve significantly, others lose a notable fraction of correct answers. The authors compare three runtime strategies—keeping the initial answer, always accepting the revision, and selectively gating revisions—and find that the best approach depends on the model and task, suggesting that self‑correction should be treated as a revision policy rather than a uniformly beneficial second pass.

By Tianzhu Zhang
arXiv AI
Aug 26

Right Diagnoses, Decorative Reasoning:A Perturbation Audit of Medical Chain-of-Thought

The study evaluates whether the chain-of-thought (CoT) rationales produced by medical language models truly influence their answers. Using a 30‑operator perturbation audit that modifies both the question and the CoT (e.g., severity reversal, negation flip, demographic swap, evidence ablation), the authors found that 72.9% of edits did not change the model’s answer—a high Chain‑Decoupling Rate (CDR). Across 14 large language models and four medical QA benchmarks, the CoT text had little impact on accuracy, and removing CoT prompting did not reduce performance. "whyItMatters":"The findings suggest that current medical CoT outputs may be more documentation than genuine reasoning, highlighting the need for better faithfulness checks in clinical AI systems."

By Mengzhu Xu, Jifan Gao, Xia Jiang, Yaoxin Wu, Xi Long
arXiv AI
Oct 26

Validating the Comparison, Not Just the Scorer: Why Overall Accuracy Can Mislead in Interactive LLM Evaluation

The paper argues that relying solely on overall accuracy or F1 scores to validate automatic scorers in LLM evaluation can conceal prompt‑specific errors that distort comparative results. By auditing six models on 180 invented‑entity questions across six prompts, the authors show that a scorer’s overall F1 of .916 masks substantial variation—up to 33.3%—in error rates depending on the prompt. In a second audit, differences in measured prompt effects dropped dramatically when multiple raters were used, highlighting the need to validate the exact comparison rather than the scorer alone.

By Ancil Crayton
arXiv Machine Learning
Sep 25

Return or Revise? Learning When Revision Helps Retrieval-Augmented QA

The paper investigates when it is better to return an existing draft answer or revise it using retrieved evidence in retrieval‑augmented QA systems. By grading both the draft and its candidate revision with the same correctness judge, the authors define a paired effect called recoverability and train policies to predict it before revision. Experiments on 25,870 open‑domain questions show that a recoverability‑based scorer outperforms a draft‑correctness scorer across multiple Llama setups, improving accuracy–revision trade‑offs and closing a significant portion of the oracle gap, though it still applies harmful revisions in a substantial fraction of cases.

By Nicholas Kashani Motlagh, Tim Anderson, Jeremy Gwinnup, Grant Erdmann
arXiv AI
Oct 2

Beyond Final Accuracy: Auditing Communication in LLM Multi-Agent Systems

The paper introduces Independent–Communicate–Revise (ICR), a framework that isolates communication effects in large language model multi‑agent systems by fixing initial reasoning and measuring how messages influence answer revision. ICR evaluates correction, preservation, and selectivity across four reasoning benchmarks, revealing that similar overall accuracy can mask divergent revision behaviors. The study shows that richer messages can both improve and harm outcomes, and that receiver policies can shift preservation and correction dynamics differently across tasks.

By Shixuan Li, Wei Yang, Peiyu Zhang, Anzhe Cheng, Heng Ping, Paul Bogdan
arXiv Computation and Language
Sep 28

Stale-Document Poisoning: When Outdated Retrieval Overrides Correct Model Answers

The paper introduces "stale‑document poisoning," a temporal alignment failure where outdated retrieval evidence causes retrieval‑augmented generation models to produce incorrect answers even when the model could answer correctly without retrieval. A benchmark of 317 verified knowledge reversals across medicine, law, software, and platform policy shows that outdated evidence flips 30–37% of Llama and Qwen answers, rising to 66–75% when models are explicitly instructed to trust the document. The study demonstrates that providing explicit validity information and a recency‑aware re‑ranker can substantially reduce poisoning, highlighting the need for models to assess whether retrieved evidence remains applicable.

By Md Shamim Ahmed, Lukas Galke Poech, Richard R\"{o}ttger
arXiv AI
Sep 25

Sequential knowledge editing breaks a model's ability to tell good evidence from bad, without costing it accuracy

The paper investigates how sequential knowledge editing can degrade a language model’s ability to discern reliable evidence from unreliable evidence without affecting overall accuracy. Using a conservatively tuned LoRA on Qwen2.5‑7B‑Instruct, the authors show that after 1,000 edits the model’s arbitration score for untouched facts drops by 36%, leading to higher error rates on its most confident decisions, while MMLU accuracy remains unchanged. The study also finds that in some model‑method combinations, sequential edits can reduce MMLU to chance levels even though edit success and locality remain perfect.

By Atul Anand